Vartika's Reviews > A Suitable Boy
A Suitable Boy
by
by
![63883678](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1652467922p2/63883678.jpg)
4.5 stars: A Great Indian Novel in both scale and scope
Those familiar with the unique dramatic phenomenon that are Hindi television soaps would see why many tend to bring them up in comparison with A Suitable Boy: both are interminably long and contend, prima facie, with the quintessentially Indian concept of arranged marriage. And yet, this is where the similarities largely end, for Vikram Seth's delightful literary behemoth extends its scope beyond the personal destinies of its characters and deals, too, with that of the fledgling democracy within which their lives come together.
At the center of this magnificent saga lies the young Lata Mehra, whose her mother's attempts to find her a suitable husband through love or through exacting maternal appraisal rope the reader into a story that intertwines four families—The Mehras, Chatterjees, Kapoors, and Khans—across a journey spanning vast tracts of Indian society, many of its vibrant cities, and the tumultuous year before the great elections in 1952 that officially turned the country into the world's largest democracy.
The colourful cast of characters reflects people from various sections of society, from academic circles in Brahmpur to a class of anglicised professionals, poets, and foreign diplomats in Calcutta; from enterprising middle-class shoe tradesmen in Kanpur to the caste-oppressed leatherworkers and untouchable tenant farmers; from the Muslim gentry in Baitar to lower-caste muslim peasants in Rudhia; from courtesans and musicians living off of royal patronage to powerful politicians—the story is knitted, plain and purl, to display the diverse, multifaceted, and often tragic social fabric of the country.
The author portrays delicacy and romance, humour and antagonism, rituals and riots, and the tragicomedy of their contingent coexistence through the immensity and realism of his pointed prose—A Suitable Boy is dramatic, but no more than lived reality, informed as it was by the painful memory of a communal Partition and the realities of class, gender, and (more prominently) caste becoming known through the electoral experiment of universal adult franchise. Seth manages to effortlessly weave into his narrative nuanced discussions on a rarely spoken about period in Indian history, including major events such as the passage and contingencies of the Zamindari Abolition Bill and the split in the Congress Party. I was pleasantly surprised to find issues such as coloniality, the oft-ignored intersection of caste with communal divide, and the Sanskritisation of 'Indian' culture and languages being discussed in what is essentially a love story with both effectiveness and subtlety.
Unlike most tales in its genre, A Suitable Boy does not shy away from exploring how politics influences personal decisions, especially those concerning marriage. Arranged marriage, in particular, is a form of maintaining the prevalent hierarchies drawn along the lines of caste, class, ethnicity and religion, and therefore a 'suitable' match for Lata would, according to convention, be a Hindu and a Khatri. Whereas the author breaks prescription in some ways, he reaffirms them in others—is it perhaps too much to ask for a truly happy ending in a story set in the 1950s? Perhaps not, but it sure isn't realistic. In any case, the tale manages ample comedy in another sense of the word: given the richness of contextual humour and subtle play of words, light-hearted cultural commentary, and other deliberate jokes, I found myself laughing out loud at several points during this book, whereas the simplicity of language and fullness of detail certainly made it a delight to read.
One of the most acclaimed books to come from the Indian subcontinent, A Suitable Boy does not disappoint: with its nuanced exploration of a host of serious themes and its serious physical bulk, it nevertheless remains light and well-rounded—much like life itself.
Those familiar with the unique dramatic phenomenon that are Hindi television soaps would see why many tend to bring them up in comparison with A Suitable Boy: both are interminably long and contend, prima facie, with the quintessentially Indian concept of arranged marriage. And yet, this is where the similarities largely end, for Vikram Seth's delightful literary behemoth extends its scope beyond the personal destinies of its characters and deals, too, with that of the fledgling democracy within which their lives come together.
At the center of this magnificent saga lies the young Lata Mehra, whose her mother's attempts to find her a suitable husband through love or through exacting maternal appraisal rope the reader into a story that intertwines four families—The Mehras, Chatterjees, Kapoors, and Khans—across a journey spanning vast tracts of Indian society, many of its vibrant cities, and the tumultuous year before the great elections in 1952 that officially turned the country into the world's largest democracy.
The colourful cast of characters reflects people from various sections of society, from academic circles in Brahmpur to a class of anglicised professionals, poets, and foreign diplomats in Calcutta; from enterprising middle-class shoe tradesmen in Kanpur to the caste-oppressed leatherworkers and untouchable tenant farmers; from the Muslim gentry in Baitar to lower-caste muslim peasants in Rudhia; from courtesans and musicians living off of royal patronage to powerful politicians—the story is knitted, plain and purl, to display the diverse, multifaceted, and often tragic social fabric of the country.
The author portrays delicacy and romance, humour and antagonism, rituals and riots, and the tragicomedy of their contingent coexistence through the immensity and realism of his pointed prose—A Suitable Boy is dramatic, but no more than lived reality, informed as it was by the painful memory of a communal Partition and the realities of class, gender, and (more prominently) caste becoming known through the electoral experiment of universal adult franchise. Seth manages to effortlessly weave into his narrative nuanced discussions on a rarely spoken about period in Indian history, including major events such as the passage and contingencies of the Zamindari Abolition Bill and the split in the Congress Party. I was pleasantly surprised to find issues such as coloniality, the oft-ignored intersection of caste with communal divide, and the Sanskritisation of 'Indian' culture and languages being discussed in what is essentially a love story with both effectiveness and subtlety.
Unlike most tales in its genre, A Suitable Boy does not shy away from exploring how politics influences personal decisions, especially those concerning marriage. Arranged marriage, in particular, is a form of maintaining the prevalent hierarchies drawn along the lines of caste, class, ethnicity and religion, and therefore a 'suitable' match for Lata would, according to convention, be a Hindu and a Khatri. Whereas the author breaks prescription in some ways, he reaffirms them in others—is it perhaps too much to ask for a truly happy ending in a story set in the 1950s? Perhaps not, but it sure isn't realistic. In any case, the tale manages ample comedy in another sense of the word: given the richness of contextual humour and subtle play of words, light-hearted cultural commentary, and other deliberate jokes, I found myself laughing out loud at several points during this book, whereas the simplicity of language and fullness of detail certainly made it a delight to read.
One of the most acclaimed books to come from the Indian subcontinent, A Suitable Boy does not disappoint: with its nuanced exploration of a host of serious themes and its serious physical bulk, it nevertheless remains light and well-rounded—much like life itself.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
A Suitable Boy.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 26, 2020
–
Started Reading
September 26, 2020
– Shelved
October 9, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)
date
newest »
![Down arrow](https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/down_arrow-1e1fa5642066c151f5e0136233fce98a.gif)
message 1:
by
Candi
(new)
-
added it
Oct 09, 2020 07:46PM
![Candi](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1703717867p1/3639005.jpg)
reply
|
flag
![Théo d'Or](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1595517509p1/98232817.jpg)
Moreover, it took me back to my youth, when names like Kapoor were highly prized in the movie market,
and arranged marriages were the predominant subject. I watched some movies even several times,
at that time the tear-jerking
movies were wreaking havoc on young people, thing which we don't see much nowadays..Ha !everyone found himself in a " suitable boy"...
![Vartika](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1652467922p1/63883678.jpg)
Moreover, it took me back to my youth, when names like Kapoor were highly prized..."
Thank you, Théodore.
As it happens, the Kapoors and Khans still continue to dominate the movie market in India, and tear-jerkers that directly or indirectly involve arranged marriage are still a staple in Bollywood--although propaganda films have become more trendy in the recent decade. I suppose they wreck havoc in a different way!
![Kafka](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1560789645p1/86784639.jpg)
![Vartika](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1652467922p1/63883678.jpg)
![Siddhartha](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1664128198p1/50650145.jpg)
![Vartika](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1652467922p1/63883678.jpg)
![Siddhartha](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1664128198p1/50650145.jpg)
![Ilse](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1686327155p1/22848274.jpg)
![Vartika](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1652467922p1/63883678.jpg)
Thank you, Ilse, I hope you get to enjoy it soon. It is indeed rare to find books that can be called so comprehensively realist (as I choose to see it), and A Suitable Boy is one of the finest examples from India.
As for Sanskritisation, it's an issue that began with the partition and seems only to have gotten worse in the present decade. In the simplest terms, it seeks to mainstream upper-caste Hindu language and traditions, which never really belonged to the masses. If you wish to, you may read more about the issue here and here.
![Deepanshu](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1701691064p1/20137866.jpg)
![Ian Laird](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1703852790p1/28547777.jpg)
![Vartika](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1652467922p1/63883678.jpg)
Thank you, Ian. I suppose the bit about sanskritisation becomes more pronounced when one is already familiar with the way caste and hierarchies operate in the subcontinent. I hope you enjoyed this book.