Candi's Reviews > The Namesake
The Namesake
by
by
"He hates that his name is both absurd and obscure, that it has nothing to do with who he is, that it is neither Indian nor American but of all things Russian. He hates having to live with it, with a pet name turned good name, day after day, second after second… At times his name, an entity shapeless and weightless, manages nevertheless to distress him physically, like the scratchy tag of a shirt he has been forced permanently to wear."
Although on the surface, it appears that Gogol Ganguli’s torment in life is due to a name that he despises, a name that doesn’t make any sense to him, the true struggle is one of identity and belonging. Jhumpa Lahiri crafts a novel full of introspection and quiet emotion as she tells the story of the immigrant experience of one Bengali family, the Gangulis. Following an arranged marriage, Ashoke and Ashima Ganguli move to America to begin a new life in Cambridge, Massachusetts. While Ashoke has the distraction of a professional career, Ashima feels lost and adrift without family, friends, and the comfort of familiar surroundings. In fact, Ashima will spend decades trying to make a life for herself, trying to fit into a culture that is so alien to the one she has left behind. Upon the birth of her first child, Ashima feels so utterly alone without family by her side to support her and welcome this new baby. "As she strokes and suckles and studies her son, she can’t help but pity him. She has never known of a person entering the world so alone, so deprived." Thus begins Gogol’s life and his pursuit towards understanding and establishing his own identity as a first generation American born to Indian immigrants.
Named after Russian writer Nikolai Gogol, our developing protagonist will scorn not only his name but also his parent’s traditions, their quiet ways, their trips to Calcutta to visit family, and their “adopted” Bengali family in America – those friends with similar immigrant experiences to their own. Instead, he yearns to shed his namesake, one that holds special significance in his father’s life for reasons that have yet to be revealed to Gogol himself. I have to wonder if Gogol had earlier learned the extraordinary meaning of this name to his father’s own personal experience, then perhaps Gogol’s approach towards life would have been different. But, in a sense this is a coming of age story for Gogol and perhaps the timing would not have mattered so much as his own maturing and growth. We see Gogol and his sister Sonia embracing American ways – eating Thanksgiving turkeys, preparing for Santa Claus, and coloring Easter eggs – while Ashoke and Ashima continue to expose them to the Bengali customs and celebrations. Once Gogol sets off for college, he attempts to leave behind much of his parent’s influence as well as his name. But in changing a name can a young man really erase his heritage and begin a life ignoring the expectations of his parents, the imprint of their culture? Isn’t this a part of him, just as much as are the American ways and customs? Does he truly need to put aside one way of life in order to find complete happiness in another? Through a series of relationships and life events, Gogol does transform over time, or so I believe, but not without his share of trials and heartache.
Jhumpa Lahiri has a gift for penetrating the psyche of each of her characters. It seems there is always something a reader can relate to in each of them, in one way or another – whether likeable or not. Each character is flawed just as every human being is imperfect. I don’t think that one needs to understand the immigrant experience to connect with this book. The Namesake is completely relatable to anyone that has ever strived to fit in, to find an identity, to accept those around us for what they are, not what we think they should be.
"Things that should never have happened, that seemed out of place and wrong, these were what prevailed, what endured, in the end."
Although on the surface, it appears that Gogol Ganguli’s torment in life is due to a name that he despises, a name that doesn’t make any sense to him, the true struggle is one of identity and belonging. Jhumpa Lahiri crafts a novel full of introspection and quiet emotion as she tells the story of the immigrant experience of one Bengali family, the Gangulis. Following an arranged marriage, Ashoke and Ashima Ganguli move to America to begin a new life in Cambridge, Massachusetts. While Ashoke has the distraction of a professional career, Ashima feels lost and adrift without family, friends, and the comfort of familiar surroundings. In fact, Ashima will spend decades trying to make a life for herself, trying to fit into a culture that is so alien to the one she has left behind. Upon the birth of her first child, Ashima feels so utterly alone without family by her side to support her and welcome this new baby. "As she strokes and suckles and studies her son, she can’t help but pity him. She has never known of a person entering the world so alone, so deprived." Thus begins Gogol’s life and his pursuit towards understanding and establishing his own identity as a first generation American born to Indian immigrants.
Named after Russian writer Nikolai Gogol, our developing protagonist will scorn not only his name but also his parent’s traditions, their quiet ways, their trips to Calcutta to visit family, and their “adopted” Bengali family in America – those friends with similar immigrant experiences to their own. Instead, he yearns to shed his namesake, one that holds special significance in his father’s life for reasons that have yet to be revealed to Gogol himself. I have to wonder if Gogol had earlier learned the extraordinary meaning of this name to his father’s own personal experience, then perhaps Gogol’s approach towards life would have been different. But, in a sense this is a coming of age story for Gogol and perhaps the timing would not have mattered so much as his own maturing and growth. We see Gogol and his sister Sonia embracing American ways – eating Thanksgiving turkeys, preparing for Santa Claus, and coloring Easter eggs – while Ashoke and Ashima continue to expose them to the Bengali customs and celebrations. Once Gogol sets off for college, he attempts to leave behind much of his parent’s influence as well as his name. But in changing a name can a young man really erase his heritage and begin a life ignoring the expectations of his parents, the imprint of their culture? Isn’t this a part of him, just as much as are the American ways and customs? Does he truly need to put aside one way of life in order to find complete happiness in another? Through a series of relationships and life events, Gogol does transform over time, or so I believe, but not without his share of trials and heartache.
Jhumpa Lahiri has a gift for penetrating the psyche of each of her characters. It seems there is always something a reader can relate to in each of them, in one way or another – whether likeable or not. Each character is flawed just as every human being is imperfect. I don’t think that one needs to understand the immigrant experience to connect with this book. The Namesake is completely relatable to anyone that has ever strived to fit in, to find an identity, to accept those around us for what they are, not what we think they should be.
"Things that should never have happened, that seemed out of place and wrong, these were what prevailed, what endured, in the end."
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Namesake.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 25, 2014
– Shelved as:
to-read
April 25, 2014
– Shelved
April 27, 2015
– Shelved as:
book-i-own
July 25, 2016
–
Started Reading
July 25, 2016
– Shelved as:
contemporary-literary
July 31, 2016
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Ian
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Apr 24, 2016 12:00AM
Could you read this please - I would be so keen to hear what you think.
reply
|
flag
Ian wrote: "Could you read this please - I would be so keen to hear what you think."
Ian, I am actually planning to read this one this summer - I have a buddy read scheduled with a friend or two so it's definitely a go! I will post a review once finished :)
Ian, I am actually planning to read this one this summer - I have a buddy read scheduled with a friend or two so it's definitely a go! I will post a review once finished :)
Candi wrote: "Ian wrote: "Could you read this please - I would be so keen to hear what you think."
Ian, I am actually planning to read this one this summer - I have a buddy read scheduled with a friend or two s..."I'm so glad, it was my book of the year for 2014. As you know she writes beautifully.
Ian, I am actually planning to read this one this summer - I have a buddy read scheduled with a friend or two s..."I'm so glad, it was my book of the year for 2014. As you know she writes beautifully.
Jhumpa Lahiri became one of my favorite authors after reading this book. I just love how honestly, yet tenderly she describes how people feel.
Terry wrote: "Jhumpa Lahiri became one of my favorite authors after reading this book. I just love how honestly, yet tenderly she describes how people feel."
I really love Lahiri's writing. You are right, Terry, it just feels so real and genuine. I am hoping to read The Lowland next.
I really love Lahiri's writing. You are right, Terry, it just feels so real and genuine. I am hoping to read The Lowland next.
Jen wrote: "Great review - I must have missed this one. I own it and looks like a good one!"
Thank you, Jen! I hope you get a chance to read this one! Would love to hear your thoughts :)
Thank you, Jen! I hope you get a chance to read this one! Would love to hear your thoughts :)
Esil wrote: "Great review Candi. I love Lahiri's books."
Thank you, Esil :) She is one of my favorites.
Thank you, Esil :) She is one of my favorites.
What a stunning review. Again, you have brought me to an author and a book that I would probably have passed otherwise. I have put it on my short-list, which means I will try to get to it early next year.
Sara wrote: "What a stunning review. Again, you have brought me to an author and a book that I would probably have passed otherwise. I have put it on my short-list, which means I will try to get to it early nex..."
Thanks so much, Sara! I really hope that you enjoy this author and this book. I find that her novels are all about the characters and less plot-driven. But I always find myself nodding my head along the way.
Thanks so much, Sara! I really hope that you enjoy this author and this book. I find that her novels are all about the characters and less plot-driven. But I always find myself nodding my head along the way.
Anushree Sharma wrote: "Actually Sara Stager is correct....It is a STUNNING review"
Thank you very much, Anushree! So kind of you to say so :)
Thank you very much, Anushree! So kind of you to say so :)
Cheri wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi. Added!"
Thank you, Cheri! I look forward to hearing your thoughts if you get a chance to read this :)
Thank you, Cheri! I look forward to hearing your thoughts if you get a chance to read this :)
Christine wrote: "A most impressive review, Candi! So well written."
Thank you, Christine! I really appreciate you taking the time to read it :)
Thank you, Christine! I really appreciate you taking the time to read it :)
Candi you write so elegantly. I so look forward to bumping into more of your reviews. Nice to meet you my new GR friend.
PorshaJo wrote: "Great review! This is such a wonderful book. A fav of mine."
Thank you, PorshaJo! I'm so happy to see so many Lahiri fans here!
Thank you, PorshaJo! I'm so happy to see so many Lahiri fans here!
Karen wrote: "Great in depth review Candi--I concur completely."
Karen, thank you! Have you read any of her other novels? I have read Interpreter of Maladies and Unaccustomed Earth and can highly recommend those if you haven't already read :)
Karen, thank you! Have you read any of her other novels? I have read Interpreter of Maladies and Unaccustomed Earth and can highly recommend those if you haven't already read :)
This is a wonderful story, I don't know if you guys are aware but there is a movie for this and I loved it so much that I recommend it to everyone. I also own a copy and watch it every once and awhile, I think I love it a little more every time I see it. This is a gem, so damn good!!!
Lisa wrote: "This is a wonderful story, I don't know if you guys are aware but there is a movie for this and I loved it so much that I recommend it to everyone. I also own a copy and watch it every once and awh..."
Lisa, thank you for the tip about the movie! I had heard there was a movie, but had actually forgotten until reading your note here! I would love to watch it :)
Lisa, thank you for the tip about the movie! I had heard there was a movie, but had actually forgotten until reading your note here! I would love to watch it :)
An amazing review Candi! I knew nothing about this author previously, and am now keen to read her work (I taught children from Bangladesh for many years...)
Aparna wrote: "Fantastic review Candi..I have seen the movie..would love to read the book someday..!"
Thank you, Aparna! If you get a chance to read the book, I would recommend this - or anything by Jhumpa Lahiri really. I have not yet read one I don't like :)
Thank you, Aparna! If you get a chance to read the book, I would recommend this - or anything by Jhumpa Lahiri really. I have not yet read one I don't like :)
Jean wrote: "An amazing review Candi! I knew nothing about this author previously, and am now keen to read her work (I taught children from Bangladesh for many years...)"
Jean, thanks so much. There is something that really draws me to this author and her characters. She seems to really understand people and their thoughts in just simple, everyday situations. In this book in particular, I also enjoyed learning more about the Bengali customs and traditions.
Jean, thanks so much. There is something that really draws me to this author and her characters. She seems to really understand people and their thoughts in just simple, everyday situations. In this book in particular, I also enjoyed learning more about the Bengali customs and traditions.
Jane wrote: "Thank you putting into words all the emotion this novel evoked in me as I read it."
Jane, thank you so much for taking the time to read my review. I'm so glad it brought back some of this lovely book for you :)
Jane, thank you so much for taking the time to read my review. I'm so glad it brought back some of this lovely book for you :)
Indrani wrote: "Thank you Candi for the amazing review. I can actually relate a lot to this book, being Bengali myself but brought up outside of India. I read only a few pages of this when I was in high school as ..."
Thank you so much, Indrani. I hope that I did this book justice with my review, and I am so glad that I pointed you back to reading it fully :)
Thank you so much, Indrani. I hope that I did this book justice with my review, and I am so glad that I pointed you back to reading it fully :)
Eileen wrote: "Excellent review as always, Candi! I love the depth of immigrant stories."
Thank you, Eileen!
Thank you, Eileen!
Just popping in to say that I finally got to this one, Candi, and as usual, you did not steer me wrong. I loved it and wanted to say how much I appreciate and value your opinions.
Sara wrote: "Just popping in to say that I finally got to this one, Candi, and as usual, you did not steer me wrong. I loved it and wanted to say how much I appreciate and value your opinions."
Sara, I'm thrilled that I steered you towards this one and that you loved it! I am so thankful that we have this opportunity through GR to share books and thoughts with like-minded readers and people like you I can call a friend :)
Sara, I'm thrilled that I steered you towards this one and that you loved it! I am so thankful that we have this opportunity through GR to share books and thoughts with like-minded readers and people like you I can call a friend :)
Kati wrote: "Great review, I am little more than half way into the book and enjoying it very much."
Oh wonderful, Kati. I hope that you continue to enjoy this one. It's a very memorable read. Thank you for commenting :)
Oh wonderful, Kati. I hope that you continue to enjoy this one. It's a very memorable read. Thank you for commenting :)